![]() |
| Image: Pong / FreeDigitalPhotos.net |
Writing advice contains so many either/or propositions. You must choose: Will you stay true to your art or prostitute yourself by doing hack writing? Will you go with a "legitimate" publisher or choose self-publishing? Each question is posed as if there's only one right answer. Everyone knows that a true writer only writes for the joy of it, never takes on hack jobs, and never, ever self publishes. To do otherwise means you aren't a "real" writer. Or does it?
Years ago a well-known YA editor once posed the question to a group of us at a conference: "Would you rather be known as a literary writer or be a commercial success?" He went around the table and people made their choices. Interestingly enough, those who chose money over craft felt the need to defend their preference. When he came to me, I said, "I'd rather be both at the same time." Everyone just stared at me, including the editor. Apparently, no one had considered the two did not have to be mutually exclusive. Since then, many YAs have been written that are both literary and bestsellers, so it isn't an impossibility.
As creatives we should be the last to embrace an either/or mentality, but should always look for ways to be inclusive. What is brainstorming? Coming up with off-the-wall, unusual ideas and then making them work. So why can't we do that with the traditional dos and don'ts of the craft? Expand our viewpoints to include all of the above?
This may be a rather long-winded way of introducing myself and my rather checkered writing career. I've tried to do it all, which means that I've been traditionally published, done ghostwriting, worked for hire, and written for the sheer joy of it. I've written fiction and nonfiction, have both e-books and print books, published for both children and adults, and been on both sides of the editorial desk. I've written under multiple pseudonyms and under my own name. I've struggled doing other jobs (teacher, children's librarian, restaurant cashier, business owner) while collecting publishing credits that paid in free copies of the magazine or journal, and I've also spent the past 6+ years totally supporting my family through my writing. And if there's one thing I've learned--it's OK to do it all. The truth is that I want it all: glory, gain, and fun. Don't you?
About the Author
After careers as a teacher and
children’s librarian, Laurie J. Edwards moved into editing and writing, where she freelances
for a variety of publishing houses. She writes for both children and adults under
several pseudonyms. In addition to having more than 1800 magazine and educational
articles published, her most recent releases include Pirates through the Ages (Cengage, 2011), Rihanna (People in the News) (Lucent, 2009), Summer Lovin’ (Wild Rose Press, 2009), and the 5-vol. Encyclopedia of North American Tribes (Gale,
2012). She is also ghostwriting an MG action-adventure series and a YA
historical fiction series. Other WIPs include a YA fantasy trilogy, a YA historical set in Ming China, and several adult novels.

7 comments:
Good post,Laurie.
Like you, I've done it all - or at least most of what you've done. I've been pen for hire, have ghostwritten about 20 titles for industry professionals (all non fiction), written articles and written for adults and kids and YAs.
And I say every bit helps. Every bit improves your writing skills. Whatever form you're involved in makes you a better writer in the long run.
Good luck to you, Laurie and I hope your successes continue in 2012 and beyond.
Welcome, Laurie. We're so pleased to have you with us.
Welcome, Laurie! And I'm with you--given the choice, I'd rather be both.
Hi Laurie! Welcome and hope you enjoy being part of this group. It feels odd not to write a post for Saturday, but with the new schedule it was a good break! Looking forward to reading more of your posts.
Thanks, everyone, for the warm welcome. I'm so glad to be part of a group of such prolific YA writers.
Love that out-of-the-box thinking, Laurie! Why let anyone (including that editor) define what success looks like? Success looks different to each of us. It even looks different at different points in our careers. And with e-publishing totally rearranging the playing field, who's to say? Do what makes you happy, whatever that is. The only rule, especially in today's market, is that there are no rules. As Outback Steakhouse says (but with slightly different spelling), "No Rules, Just Write!"
Enjoyed your post, Laurie. Lots to think about. Sounds like you've had a lot of experience with many different facets of publishing.
Post a Comment